Starting a retinoid without wrecking your skin
Some links in this article are affiliate links. I may earn a commission when you shop them, at no extra cost to you.
If you only ever add one active to your routine, this is the one I would choose. Retinoids have more evidence behind them than anything else on a shelf.
Why a retinoid, of everything
Prescription retinoids have been studied and prescribed for decades, which means we know well what they do and how they behave over years of use. They speed up cell turnover, help build collagen, and improve texture and pigment in a way nothing else quite matches. That track record is the reason I am willing to ask patients to brave it through an adjustment period, which is not something I do lightly.
Start low, go slow
So here is the part I want to be clear about, because it is easy to fall off the train before really giving it a chance. Start low, go slow. A retinoid only works if you use it consistently over months, so the goal is not the strongest product you can tolerate for two weeks. The goal is one you can genuinely use at least every other night, indefinitely, and build up to over time. A gentle retinoid used four nights a week for a year will outperform a strong one abandoned a few weeks in. And as your skin builds a tolerance, you can slowly level up to more potent formulations over time.
The categories, and what the box means
The categories are worth understanding, since the words on the front of a box are doing a lot of work. Prescription tretinoin is retinoic acid itself, which needs no conversion before binding to the retinoid receptor in the skin. It comes in several strengths so it can be matched to your individual needs. Adapalene is worth knowing about separately, because it is a true retinoid that binds the receptor directly, the way tretinoin does, and yet it is available over the counter at 0.1 percent. It was developed for acne and it is unusually stable and well tolerated, so it is a sensible choice for anyone who wants that chemistry without a prescription. Over the counter, retinol has to convert before it becomes active in the skin's retinoid receptor, which makes it milder and slower, but it still gets the job done. Retinaldehyde sits one step closer to the active form, so it tends to do more than retinol without the jump in irritation people expect. Granactive retinoid is a newer ester designed to be better tolerated again. There are also excellent hybrid formulas that pair a retinoid with a gentle acid, and those can be both effective and unusually comfortable. One thing worth knowing: comparing percentages across these categories is not apples to apples. A 1% retinol and a 0.1% retinaldehyde are not two points on the same scale, because each form performs differently in the skin and each has to undergo a different number of chemical conversions before it reaches its active state. The number on the front of the box only means something within a single form.
This is also the point where I would say that a prescription is worth a conversation. A dermatologist can look at your skin, your history and what else you are using, then choose a strength accordingly, which is a much better process than guessing from a shelf.
If your skin needs something gentler
If your skin is genuinely sensitive, or a retinoid has gone badly before, bakuchiol is a real alternative rather than a consolation prize. It is a plant-derived ingredient that acts on the same receptor as retinol and produces much of the same effect with noticeably less inflammation. I have patients who have stayed on bakuchiol permanently and are perfectly happy there. It is also a good answer for more mature skin that tolerated a retinol comfortably for years and no longer does, which is more common than people expect. And it works beautifully on the off nights, so if you are using a retinoid every other night you can use bakuchiol in between and never leave a gap.
The first six weeks
What the first six weeks actually look like: some mild redness and flaking, most of it around the eyes and the mouth where skin is thinnest. Stay well away from the eyes, and put extra moisturizer around the mouth before you apply. That much is expected and it settles. What is not expected is burning, real soreness, or skin that feels raw. If you get there, take several nights off and let the barrier recover before you go back at a lower frequency. Nothing is lost by pausing.
For sensitive skin, and for anyone restarting after a bad experience, the sandwich method is worth using from the beginning. Moisturizer first, retinoid on top, moisturizer again. It slows absorption slightly, and the trade is well worth it. Keep acids and benzoyl peroxide out of the same routine entirely, on different nights or not at all.
Before you start
Two things before you start. If you are pregnant or trying to become pregnant, retinoids are out, and that includes over the counter. And if you are about to spend a week somewhere sunny, that is not the week to begin. Sunscreen matters even more than usual once you are using one.
What to expect, and when
As for results, the honest timeline is texture in weeks, and pigment and fine lines in months. Skin usually feels smoother well before it looks different in photographs, which is the part people find frustrating. It is worth staying with anyway, since this is the one active where the years genuinely compound.
A note: this article is general education, not medical advice, and it cannot account for your history or medications. Retinoids are not for use in pregnancy. If something on your skin is changing, painful, or not responding, see a board-certified dermatologist in person.
Rebecca Marcus, MD
Board-certified dermatologist and the founder of Maei MD. I write about what works, what does not, and what is simply beautiful.
This article is general education, not medical advice, and reading it does not create a doctor–patient relationship. For your own skin, please see a board-certified dermatologist.
Rebecca Marcus, MD
Board-certified dermatologist and the founder of Maei MD. I write about what works, what does not, and what is simply beautiful. My hope is that you end up owning fewer things and loving all of them.
More about meKeep reading
Hair loss on a GLP-1: what the evidence actually shows, and how to protect your hair
A dermatologist on why GLP-1 shedding starts at month three, what the studies actually found, and what to s...
How to choose a vitamin C serum for your skin type
Beauty How to choose a vitamin C serum for your skin type By Rebecca Marcus, MD · Septembe...
Why tinted sunscreen works better for melasma
A dermatologist on why iron oxides in tinted sunscreen protect against the visible light that drives melasm...